UNlimited possibilities

Lindy has baked over 77,000 cookies in every conceivable shape and theme. There are no limits on what we can create, because the driving force is

Your imagination.

PRICING

But really, can you put a price on joy?

Custom Shapes/ Detailing

$2.50/Cookie $30/Dozen

Let's get creative.

Gluten Free

$3.00/Cookie $36/Dozen

A healthful option!

3+ Dozen

$25/Dozen Custom $30/Dozen Gluten Free

More = Better

*Preorder*

Halloween Platter

$26

Order October 12-16 for pick up on 10/28, 10/29 or 10/30.

*Special*

Halloween DIY Kits

$25/Dozen

Create joy at home!

*Special*

You've Been Boo'd

$11

Pack of 4 cookies for you to gift to your neighbors!

Order Today

Contact us for a more accurate quote on your order.

Available at:

Lindy

Started using her passion for baking cookies to bless those she cared about. But soon word got around and people started asking to place orders. Seeds were planted and excitement grew.

This is the result.

How We Do IT

This recipe has been in the works and being perfected over the last 20 years. Our cookies are made with only 9 ingredients – all of which you can pronounce. Basic. Simple. All natural. Yummy goodness. Melt in your mouth. Custom designed. Gluten free, vegan, and dairy free are all options, too.

We have the privilege of baking our cookies at Venture Christian Church in Carmel, IN.

Meet the Team

Carli Pratt

Kitchen Manager

Lindy Siefker

Owner

Jodi Wenthe

Business Manager

inspiration

Animals

Misc

Business

Seasons

Events

Sports

Holiday

The Arts

“ I have ordered Lindy’s cookies for many years & for many occasions. Her over the top cookie decorating is gorgeous and her flavor, predictably delicious. Around Thanksgiving, I order a mix of fall related cookies (my favorite is the petite acorn beautifully adorned with golden sugar). It is not hard to impress my real estate clients as I surprise them with this bag of assorted cookies! Lindy helps make me look good in my business!”

LINDA TATUM, Realtor

“I can’t say enough about Lindy’s cookies. I once bought a dozen pretending it was for my family…I ate nine of them on the car ride home. The cookies balance both a perfect amount of flour and sugar, and have just the right amount of icing. Most importantly, Lindy makes them herself. She demands perfection. To make them right, she makes them herself. Everyone who buys cookies from Lindy has a story that Lindy becomes a part of. Whether it’s someone’s first birthday, a friend’s graduation, or, in my case, someone hungry for a dozen great cookies, everyone has a good reason to ask Lindy’s cookies to become a part of their story. Lindy’s cookies perfectly balance the amount of icing, sugar, and flour. They are high quality because Lindy demands high quality of herself. I love Lindy’s cookies. In fact, excuse me for a moment while I order some more.

JOEL KIRK

“I love ordering from Lindy! Her cookies are a staple at all of our holiday gatherings. In fact, it wouldn’t feel like a celebration without them now! Whatever the event, I feel that she actually celebrates the occasion right along with me by prayerfully creating each and every cookie with a design that is so specific and detailed to my need. Everyone I send them to raves about the taste, texture and custom designs! Plus, her gluten free recipe is the best we’ve ever had! If I want to make someone feel celebrated and special, Lindy’s Cookies is my go-to every single time!”

JORI MACNULTY

“I enjoy these cookies more than I should admit. There is something about them that really brings me joy, deep down, when I see them. I highly recommend these to everyone. And surprisingly, the gluten free cookies are just as good!!”

Marcus Casteel

delicious iced sugar cookies + whimsical design = JOy in a box

Let’s chat about your upcoming event or the special person you want to delight. Our passion is delivering smiles and joy to every customer we serve. Let’s brainstorm! Our favorite part of the process is working with you to come up with just the right design to fulfill your vision. Our joy comes from seeing delight from those we serve. You want to deliver a box of joy to someone who doesn’t live nearby? No problem. WE SHIP!