We'll see you soon!
It has been an amazing two years, but Lindy’s Cookies will be ceasing operations until further notice due to staff shortage. We have appreciated your business and have some of the best customers around. Thank you from all of us on the Lindy’s Cookies Team!!

UNlimited possibilities
Lindy has baked over 77,000 cookies in every conceivable shape and theme. There are no limits on what we can create, because the driving force is
Your imagination.

PRICING
But really, can you put a price on joy?
Cookies of the Week
$30/Dozen
+ Tax
Need cookies but don’t know what to order? Each week our bakers come up with a fun and creative theme for our vendors that we offer at a discounted rate to you! Minimum order of a Dozen.
Theme Cookies
$32/Dozen
+ Tax
Have a special event coming up? Pick from one of our predesigned Themes and we’ll do the rest! Theme cookies come with 4 designs with your choice of 2 colors and must be ordered by the dozen. See descriptions of the designs here.
Custom Cookies
Starting at
$35/Dozen + Tax
If you can dream it up, we can make it! Custom Cookies pricing is based on complexity and number of individual designs. You’ll receive a more accurate quote after submitting your order. Minimum order of 6 cookies.
Contact us for a more accurate quote on your order.

Lindy
Started using her passion for baking cookies to bless those she cared about. But soon word got around and people started asking to place orders. Seeds were planted and excitement grew.
This is the result.
How We Do IT
This recipe has been in the works and being perfected over the last 20 years. Our cookies are made with only 9 ingredients – all of which you can pronounce. Basic. Simple. All natural. Yummy goodness. Melt in your mouth. Custom designed. Gluten free, vegan, and dairy free are all options, too.
We have the privilege of baking our cookies at Venture Christian Church in Carmel, IN.
Meet the Team

Carli Pratt
Kitchen Manager

Lindy Siefker
Owner

Jodi Wenthe
Business Manager
inspiration
delicious iced sugar cookies + whimsical design = JOy in a box
Let’s chat about your upcoming event or the special person you want to delight. Our passion is delivering smiles and joy to every customer we serve. Let’s brainstorm! Our favorite part of the process is working with you to come up with just the right design to fulfill your vision. Our joy comes from seeing delight from those we serve. You want to deliver a box of joy to someone who doesn’t live nearby? No problem. WE SHIP!
We look forward to hearing from you. Contact us below.